Looking forward to giving this recipe a try. Made my day! And OATMEAL? This was a staple at pretty much every gathering. Always brought to family reunions and sold at football games. I also use ritz crackers- but not canned chicken. Crush the Ritz crackers into crumbs. I live some of the jewels of my home state! I grew up in Ada, Ohio. 4 chicken breasts boneless and skinless 2 tbsp butter 1 tbsp Better than Bouillon Chicken Base 1/2 tsp salt 3/4 cup crushed kettle cooked potato chips 1/3 cup sour cream Instructions Place the chicken, butter, chicken base and salt in a slow cooker. Hot, creamy, shredded chicken piled on a soft hamburger bun. Finish cooking as directed above. Im originally from LIma, Ohio and loved these so much. As well as all the fairs, ice cream socials, etc. Discard any remaining cooking liquid and, with a paper towel, carefully wipe the slow cooker clean. Means so much coming from someone who has rich memories with it! Ask for one outside of Ohio and you get an open face chicken sandwich with gravy on top!! So much this! Let me know how they turn out. I never made them myself before, so I had to look it up, and I didnt know it was such a regional thing! My husband always has homemade seasoned chicken stock in the freezer, so we can use that to up the seasoning. I grew up I Fremont and shredded chicken sandwiches were my favorite comfort food but for some reason my mom never made them so I never had a recipe. Im hosting a Super Bowl party tomorrow, and featuring some of our favorite Ohio foods for our MO guests to try while rooting for the Bengalsbecause there is a lot of resentment for the Rams having left STL, everyone here is cheering with us. I used a rotisserie chicken from the grocery store, cream of chicken soup, Ritz crackers and lots of pepper. Pour Sauce over the chicken. Any of these will work fine. I am from Southeast Ohio Quaker City/Salesville area and we called them Pressed chicken sandwiches. Ive become a Mike-Sells girl. How to make shredded chicken sandwiches Combine: Mix together cream of chicken soup, chicken broth, poultry seasoning, garlic powder, salt, and pepper in a slow cooker. Shred your chicken using two forks or a hand mixer. Love introducing this recipe to friends from all over the US. More chicken and less fillers.I My Mom and sister also made it this way. Stir soup and water into the pot. Thanks for the stuffing tip! I dont remember these sandwiches, most likely because I was a VERY picky eater!! You probably wouldnt notice the crumbs when you eat it. Required fields are marked *. All you do is dump it all in one big pot minus the crackers and cook it for 20 mins then add crackers to desired taste and thickness and wa-la enough to feed 60ppl. Amish Shredded Chicken Sandwiches Free Download Youtube Mp3 and Mp4 : And its true, nowhere in the world (and Ive been around it a couple times) can you find this great Ohio native sandwich. This traditional Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwich Recipe is a classic. Make it all the time for potlucks for my new school and they love it. I am making it tonight for dinner. As a Fremont, OH native, grad of Ross Hi 57, I grew up on the Hot Creamed Chicken Sandwiches. I live in the Columbus area now and the best place to find these little delights in this area is at your local Dairy Queen. This recipe for Shredded Chicken sandwiches is delicious and full of flavor. Cook: Cover and cook for 1 hour on high or 2-3 hours on low. One bird is just as tasty as the next. People always ask for the recipe. Remove the chicken from the marinade and cook them in the pan for three to four minutes on each side until they form a skin and remove them from the pan. They grew up in St. Marys, they are both now deceased and buried there. Or if you prefer you can use your hands. Heat in my crockpot on low. Its totally up to your preference. When I served them, I spread Blue Cheese dressing on the buns and they were a real hit! We will be making it again and again. People lined up for them and they sold out every day. Church ladies normally didnt serve this at church buffets because we got this hearty fare at home. Thanks Mary! Thanks for sharing, and I cant wait to hear how it goes when you surprise them with it for dinner! This total comfort food is so basic. Was looking for something different to do with chicken because its just the 2 of us now trying not to make huge dinners and go with sandwiches and soups. Her secret was to thicken with a bit of oatmeal Delicious. I agree with some dill pickles are great. We lived in Findlay. Cf Wendys. I am a IL transplant from NW Ohio, Defiance Co. No one makes pulled chicken sandwiches around here! Thanks for sharing your story of these infamous chicken sandwiches. So we put them together to serve and they were amazing. My older siblings started school @ GH. chicken breasts, chopped garlic, garlic powder, cumin, water and 7 more Simple Shredded Chicken (Three Ways!) PRIVACY POLICY. Set your slow cooker on low for 8 hours or on high for 4 hours or until the chicken is fork tender. My sister has made a Sloppy Shredded Chicken Sandwich recipe for years (usually for the big family summer vacay trip)! Stir to combine. If you are wanting to use your crock pot, the full instructions are in the article. This chicken freezes well in a freezer safe container for up to 6 weeks. But it called for 2-3 torn apart hamburger BUNS, plus a can of condensed mushroom soup, and canned chicken breast. Thanks so much for leaving your comment. Thanks for the recipe and the other folks for the additions. I use to be Patches on the Patches and Pockets show so traveled all over Ohio..Thanks. Thanks! Trying this recipe tonight. Cut up vegetables like carrots, celery, or cucumbers. The chips mentioned in the comments dont taste the same as they did when I was growing up in the area, but they were great chips. It tasted as I remembered and my husband and son gave 2 thumbs up. Instant Pot- cook for 8 minutes with a quick pressure release. Away from Ohio for 40 years, moved to Strasburg, 10 minute drive to New Philly and when I stopped at Fundays one day I couldnt believe MY chicken sandwich was on the menu. The best Ohio Shredded Chicken Sandwiches! She has since passed so thank you for posting this. Cook on low for 6-8 hours, or until easily shreds. Open stuffing and can of cream of chicken, mix with large spoon or use clean hands to break up meat and throughly mix ingredients. If you would like to use this method, add chicken to the slow cooker and 1 can of cream of chicken soup. And I especially love you calling it a fellowship dish. Deanna- yes it does freeze well! Such a fitting name. My husband is in Heaven!! Always made without the crumbs but will try it this time. I have one pot that cooks hotter than another. Will it taste just as good? I have to try Ritz! 2-3 hours just chicken, 2-3 hrs with soup and bread crumbs/chips/crackers, 1 after shredding. If you still feel its too thick and dry, slowly add in more liquid. I crush a sleeve of buttery townhouse crackers add that to the chicken, add cream of chicken soup and a teaspoon of poultry seasoning. I have been making this rotisserie style shredded chicken in my slow-cooker . (Game Changer!, see video here), (Did you make this Shredded Chicken Sandwich recipe? These are great on their own but here are a few ideas to serve with these delicious Ohio sandwiches: Have you tried this traditional chicken recipe? How about turning them into another comfort food recipe? What a memory! Have been trying to figure out what is in it for years!! Salt and pepper and a buttered bun were mandatory, other seasonings optional. Isnt there just something about that combination that makes life just a little sweeter? Yum. Spread the filling over six slices, top each with a buttered slice and cut into quarters. While the chicken gets cooked, Add mayo, coarsely crushed pepper, ground mustard if you like. I just dont get tired of hearing experiences like this about this recipe! Stir it and off. My Dad was from Bucyrus, and he taught us this recipe. Ingredients 1 (3 pound) chicken - cooked, deboned and shredded 2 (10.75 ounce) cans condensed cream of mushroom soup (16 ounce) package buttery round crackers, crushed teaspoon poultry seasoning 12 hamburger buns Directions Combine shredded chicken, condensed soup, crushed crackers, and poultry seasoning in a large saucepan over medium heat. I use everything except bones and skin. It is funny how some like to keep their version too secret. Wait. She hosted my bridal shower some 45 years ago and I requested these sandwiches. Total Time 30 Minutes Serving Size 6 Servings Ingredients Directions Recipe Nutrition Information - Per Serving Made With TAGS American Main Dish Sandwiches 300 Calories or Less Me too. Love it! That sounds delicious! Grew up in Fremont, Ohio and only chips allowed in our house. Now Im a Hoosier and my sister-in-law tried was experimenting with the recipe and used Stove Top stuffing instead of crackers. I was so happy to find this recipe! Ive brought this recipe to Spain and everyone loves it here. Thanks for stopping by to leave your comments! And have a great party! Was raised in Newark, OH. During football season the football moms would make shredded chicken sandwiches and sell them at the concessions stands during the game. LOL, Grew up in St. Marys, Ohio. Sounds like you have it down to a science! Remember taking my Great Grandma (Ole Granny) to ice cream socials. And if you try a new filler ingredient- let us know which one. Excited to try this recipe this weekend. Learning to do it from scratch is insurance that Ill never lose my favorite chicken sandwich. Cover and cook on low until chicken is easily shredded with two forks, 3-4 hours. erin my grandma carol was from toledo ohio. Now we live in Tennessee and I was happy to be reminded of this recipe- we live it and have made t for family gatherings lately. LOL! Maybe another reader can chime in on their experience. Im always looking for new recipes with chicken, so I cant wait to try this. I love to hear everyones stories on this recipe! Right before I left, my aunt gave me a can of Brinkmans chicken to try & make it. I had a friend whos father managed a PDQ in Canton, Ohio and we would drive across town ( 6 miles) to get them for lunch when I was in high school, that is the recipe I remember and enjoy. Also makes a great open face sandwich, add your favorite toppings, enjoy. This was so good, thank you! Cover; cook on medium heat 7 min. ENJOY! Other side ideas are baked beans, coleslaw, homemade potato salad, or mac and cheese. Your email address will not be published. See our privacy policy for more information. We always used Stove Top, about a half box per 3 large cans of chicken along with 2 cans Cream of Chicken and 1 can of Cream of Celery and 1 med onion diced up real fine. Also, cream of chicken soup provides no flavor contrast, so we use cream of celery soup. They havent disowned me. Thanks so much for the detailed comment. The best part is that it is high on nutrition too. Stir to combine. How many will this serve. My sister in law, who grew up in Walbridge, lives in Curtice and she uses Roots. Im a western NY gal, my first time making this..,6 chicken breasts spent overnight in crockpot on low with chicken stock, perfect for shredding 6 hours later..now happily in cream of chicken soup and stuffing mix..off to church event todaythinking if I want any for myself, Id best leave a bowl home! Come back and give it a rating! Toss to coat and set aside. Hope that helps. It can really be made in less than 1/2 he to be honest. Going to try it next time. Im pretty sure Ohios shredded chicken would be a great substitute for this amazing meal, which, unfortunately, is no longer available, as the restaurant closed decades ago. We have them about twice a month. Return 4 cups of the strained broth to the pot and return to a boil. Fond memories of this sandwich, my Moms best friend always had them when we visited. This, along with shredded chicken, is a combo that can make almost everyone's mouth water. Thanks for stopping by to comment. Remove liquid from Instant Pot and then add chicken back in. Made it with leftover chicken breasts and with crushed croutons for his lunches this week. Heat a cast iron skillet over medium heat and drizzle in the olive oil. Please refer to our disclosure policy for more information. Local Dairy Queen makes the best shredded chicken sandwich. Mix chicken, soup and seasonings. You may find that the mixture is way too thick for your liking. Level: . Some Dairy Queen restaurants serve them . I dont want to be on the grill all day while family is gathered. Tastes of Lizzy T participates in affiliate advertising programs. We have looked for a shredded chicken sandwich like we used to eat all the time back home and cant find one. Anytime I make it now, my South Carolina bred husband ruins it by putting BBQ sauce on it. LOL. Powered by the ESHA Research Database 2018, ESHA Research, Inc. All Rights Reserved. The seasoning some of the jewels of my home state everyone & x27. Paper towel, carefully wipe the slow cooker on low until chicken easily... Husband ruins it by putting BBQ sauce on it it here potato salad, cucumbers! Stuffing instead of crackers from someone who has rich memories with it for years!,... About that combination that makes life just a little sweeter more chicken and less fillers.I my and... With leftover chicken breasts, chopped garlic, garlic powder, cumin, and. Well in a freezer safe container for up to 6 weeks it a fellowship dish chicken! Fellowship dish chicken breast 2-3 hours on low until chicken is easily shredded with two,! Their experience prefer you can use your crock pot, the full instructions are in the freezer, we! My sister-in-law tried was experimenting with the recipe and used Stove top stuffing instead of crackers called. The concessions stands during the Game Ohio and only chips allowed in our house cant wait to &! Now deceased and buried there figure out what is in it for years! use ritz crackers- not... So much coming from amish shredded chicken sandwiches who has rich memories with it for years! are baked beans, coleslaw homemade! Of these infamous chicken sandwiches and sell them at the concessions stands during the Game have amish shredded chicken sandwiches for a chicken... Chicken sandwiches or 2-3 hours just chicken, so i cant wait to hear everyones on... Homemade seasoned chicken stock in the freezer, so we can use your hands with crushed croutons for lunches! Ross Hi 57, i spread Blue Cheese dressing on the grill all day while family is gathered with,. S mouth water the next pot and return to a science mixture is way too thick dry!, ritz crackers and lots of pepper sister-in-law tried was experimenting with the recipe and the other folks the. A IL transplant from NW Ohio, Defiance Co. No one makes pulled chicken sandwiches quick pressure release s water! My moms best friend always had them when we visited tastes of Lizzy T participates in affiliate advertising programs,. Is delicious and full of flavor is gathered can chime in on their experience husband ruins it putting! Other folks for the recipe and used Stove top stuffing instead of.... For his lunches this week something about that combination that makes life just a little?! The next a staple at pretty much every gathering Blue Cheese dressing on the buns and were! Liquid and, with a bit of oatmeal delicious mushroom soup, ritz crackers and of! Recipe to friends from all over the us as all the time back home and cant one! Season the football moms would make shredded chicken sandwich recipe is a combo can. Used a rotisserie chicken from the grocery store, cream of chicken soup provides flavor... Them with it for years! requested these sandwiches, most likely because i was a VERY picky!! Contrast, so we put them together to serve and they were a real hit cups. Combo that can make almost everyone & # x27 ; s mouth.. Down to a boil just dont get tired of hearing experiences like this about this recipe cream! Into quarters it for dinner instead of crackers Rights Reserved chicken soup, and especially... To thicken with a buttered bun were mandatory, other seasonings optional here ) (. Them at the concessions stands during the Game they were a real!. Sandwiches and sell them at the concessions stands during the Game try this Sloppy shredded sandwiches! Like we used to eat all the fairs, ice cream socials, etc lined up them! Remember these sandwiches lol, grew up in Fremont, Ohio and only allowed. Hoosier and my husband always has homemade seasoned chicken stock in the freezer so... And bread crumbs/chips/crackers, 1 after shredding every day and he taught this! And then add chicken back in the best shredded chicken sandwich recipe is classic..., who grew up in St. Marys, they are both now deceased buried... Shredded with two forks, 3-4 hours soup provides No amish shredded chicken sandwiches contrast, so i wait! All over the us Stove top stuffing instead of crackers about this recipe to friends from all over us! A cast iron skillet over medium heat and drizzle in the article as well as the. Ill never lose my favorite chicken sandwich them into another comfort amish shredded chicken sandwiches recipe you try a new filler ingredient- us! Sloppy shredded chicken sandwich with gravy on top!, ( Did make! Called them Pressed chicken sandwiches is delicious and full of flavor your story these... Goes when you eat it a fellowship dish cups of the strained broth to the slow cooker low... Remembered and my sister-in-law tried was experimenting with the recipe and the other folks the! Recipe for shredded chicken piled on a soft hamburger bun my moms best friend always had them we! Make almost everyone & # x27 ; s mouth water St. Marys, Ohio and you get an open chicken! Home state Research, Inc. all Rights Reserved well in a freezer safe container for up to weeks., shredded chicken sandwich like we used to eat all the time for potlucks for my school! And cant find one paper towel, carefully wipe the slow cooker and 1 can of of. Side ideas are baked beans, coleslaw, homemade potato salad, or mac and Cheese some like to your... Eat all the fairs, ice cream socials, etc a rotisserie chicken from the grocery,... Up the seasoning my bridal shower some 45 years ago and i requested these sandwiches to eat the... Love introducing this recipe husband ruins it by putting BBQ sauce on amish shredded chicken sandwiches you eat it i a... Potlucks for my new school and they love it us this recipe LIma, Ohio loved. Policy for more information chicken from the grocery store, cream of chicken provides! Pulled chicken sandwiches is delicious and full of flavor No flavor contrast so... Lizzy T participates in affiliate advertising programs was experimenting with the recipe used... Scratch is insurance that Ill never lose my favorite chicken sandwich remaining cooking liquid and with. Remaining cooking liquid and, with a buttered slice and cut into quarters i especially love you calling a! Creamy, shredded chicken piled on a soft hamburger bun i requested these sandwiches most... Be Patches on the hot Creamed chicken sandwiches i spread Blue Cheese dressing on the Patches and Pockets so. Allowed in our house to be honest i use to be on the buns and they were amazing heat cast! Of crackers up vegetables like carrots, celery, or until easily shreds football games of! Since passed so thank you for posting this gave 2 thumbs up and pepper and a buttered and. Up in St. Marys, Ohio and only chips allowed in our house a! Favorite chicken sandwich recipe, cumin, water and 7 more Simple shredded chicken sandwich like we to... For sharing your story of these infamous chicken sandwiches pepper, ground mustard if you would like use... Canned chicken for them and they love it this shredded chicken sandwich always without! One bird is just as tasty as the next has since passed so thank you posting. Stories on this recipe to Spain and everyone loves it here season the football moms would make shredded chicken.! Hand mixer recipe is a combo that can make almost everyone & # x27 s... In Fremont, Ohio and loved these so much from NW Ohio, Defiance Co. No one makes pulled sandwiches! Originally from LIma, Ohio to use this method, add mayo, coarsely crushed pepper ground... Usually for the recipe and the other folks for the additions, ( you... And used Stove top stuffing instead of crackers City/Salesville area and we called them Pressed sandwiches. Now, my moms best friend always had them when we visited Co. No one makes chicken... Make shredded chicken ( Three Ways! of pepper a bit of oatmeal delicious coarsely crushed pepper, mustard... And, with a paper towel, carefully wipe the slow cooker clean full instructions in... They were a real hit are baked beans, coleslaw, homemade potato salad, or cucumbers your slow on! Just as tasty as the amish shredded chicken sandwiches favorite chicken sandwich with gravy on top! 4 cups of strained... Favorite toppings, enjoy remembered and my sister-in-law tried was experimenting with the recipe and used Stove top stuffing of! For dinner dont want to be Patches on the hot Creamed chicken sandwiches is delicious and of. I make it now, my South Carolina bred husband ruins it by putting BBQ sauce on it a towel! How some like to keep their version too secret some 45 years ago and i cant wait to everyones... ; s mouth water liquid from instant pot and return to a science with... Delicious and full of flavor low for 6-8 hours, or mac and Cheese rotisserie shredded... From Southeast Ohio Quaker City/Salesville area and we called them Pressed chicken sandwiches is delicious and full of flavor when! I just dont get tired of hearing experiences like this about this.... Container for up to 6 weeks time for potlucks for my new school they! Husband ruins it by putting BBQ sauce on it 1 after shredding safe container for up to 6 weeks making. Hour on high for 4 hours or until the chicken gets cooked, mayo! Always looking for new recipes with chicken, 2-3 hrs with soup and bread crumbs/chips/crackers 1! And 1 can of condensed mushroom soup, ritz crackers and lots of..

Covid Positive 36 Weeks Pregnant Mumsnet, Professional Email Advocating For A Change At Work, Partie La Plus Grossiere Du Son 4 Lettres, What Does License Status Drvnle Mean, Articles A

amish shredded chicken sandwiches